There is often confusion as to when a divot should be replaced, and when the sand mix should be used. In an effort to clear things up, let's keep it simple:
If your divot doesn't explode, and has some bit of soil with it, please replace it.
There are many variables that come into play in determining if the divot will live or not. This obviously includes the weather, and the location (slope vs swale). However, even in the summer, there's a decent chance that a replaced divot will survive.
Below you can see the divot on the right was replaced and has already knitted back in nicely. In contrast, the divot on the left is, to be kind, a real head-scratcher.
So save that sand mix for the times when your divot can't be replaced. And please don't get too fancy--we've seen well intentioned players make a sandwich with a sprinkle of divot mix, the divot itself, and a bit more mix on top for good measure. Remember, more isn't always better.